Caraglio's Pizza Menu

Welcome to Caraglio's Pizza, a beloved gem located at 2186 Empire Blvd in Webster, NY. This pizzeria excels in offering a delightful range of pizzas, from medium to small sizes, where you can customize your experience with a variety of sauces—red, white, pink, or none. Customers rave about the perfect crust and generous toppings, including options like eggplant, bacon, and even seafood.

Their standout Sloppy Plates come packed with choice meats like pulled pork and chicken fingers, paired with delectable sides like fries and mac salad. Reviewers frequently mention the top-notch service, showcasing a commitment to customer satisfaction even when hiccups occur. With gluten-free options and a diverse beverage selection, Caraglio's Pizza isn’t just a meal, it’s an experience. Whether it's a gathering or a quick bite, this spot guarantees satisfaction and a warm welcome every time.

Menu - Pizza

Keto Bowl

No crust - includes 2 toppings, cheese, and sauces.

$8.99

Philly Steak Keto Bowl

With 2 veggies

$10.99

Chicken Philly Keto Bowl

With 2 veggies

$10.99

Small Pizza

Small pizza with choice of red, white, pink, or no sauce. Varied toppings include cheese options, meats like pepperoni and chicken, vegetables from olives to broccoli, and more.

$10.99

Medium Pizza

Medium pizza with choice of sauce: red, white, pink, or none. Toppings include vegetables, meats like chicken, ham, bacon, or seafood; cheeses like ricotta, cheddar, and extra cheese available.

$15.99

Large Pizza

Large pizza with choice of sauce: red, white, pink, or none. Select toppings from over ten options including meats, vegetables, and cheeses.

$19.99

Sheet Pizza

Large pizza with choice of sauce: red, white, pink, or none. Options include range of toppings from vegetables to meats like pepperoni and chicken, and cheeses.

$28.99

Gluten Free Pizza

Gluten-free crust, choice of red sauce or sauceless, customizable toppings.

$12.99

Calzone

1 topping include. not all toppings are gluten-free

$13.99

Extra Sauce

Variety of sauces including mild to hot, sweet BBQ options, exotic flavors like mango habanero, and classic condiments like ketchup and mustard.

$0.00

*10 Plates And Napkins*

$0.00

Calzone

1 topping include. not all toppings are gluten-free

$13.99

Breakfast Pizza Calzone

White Sauce, eggs, cheese and bacon or sausage

$17.99

Chk Wing Pizza Calzone

Stuffed with chicken wings, choice of sauce ranging from mild to hot, including sweet Thai BBQ and Caribbean jerk. Optional sauce on the side or mixed.

$17.99

CBR Calzone

Chicken and bacon smothered in mozzarella, covered with ranch

$17.99

Four Cheese Calzone

Smothered in mozzarella provolone ricotta and romano.

$17.99

Hawaiian Pizza Calzone

$17.99

Italian M.O.B. Calzone

Meatballs bacon and onions smothered in mozzarella.

$17.99

Meat Supreme Calzone

Stuffed with assorted meats. Sauce options include red, white, pink, or none.

$17.99

Pulled Pork Calzone

Texas bbq joint-pulled pork slathered in your choice of sauce covered in mozzarella.

$17.99

Red Headed Italian Calzone

White sauce smothered in mozzarella topped with red sauce and romano.

$17.99

Steak Pizza Calzone

Comes with your choice of sauce topped with shaved steak smothered in mozzarella.

$17.99

Supreme Classic Calzone

Pepperoni sausage onions black olives and sweet peppers.

$17.99

Veggie Supreme Calzone

Loaded with green bell peppers, black olives, onions, and banana peppers, all enveloped in melted cheese within a golden-brown calzone crust.

$17.99

Menu - Calzones

Menu - 20oz Beverage

Vitaminwater Dragon Fruit

Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.

$2.99

Dasani

20 oz bottle.

$2.49

Vitaminwater XXX

20 oz. bottle.

$2.99

Minute Maid Lemonade

100% Pure squeezed pasteurized orange juice. A delicious orange juice with a taste that’s the next best thing to fresh squeezed.

$2.49

20oz Coca Cola Classic

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

$2.79

20oz Diet Coke

A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

$2.79

20oz Sprite

The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.

$2.79

20oz Canada Dry Ginger Ale

$2.79

20oz Fanta Grape

Change up your routine with the bright, bubbly, fruity orange flavor.

$2.79

20oz Fanta Orange

Change up your routine with the bright, bubbly, fruity orange flavor.

$2.79

20oz Barqs Root Beer

A sweet, spiced favorite that’s stood the test of time.

$2.79

20oz Dr Pepper

Classic Soda with a Unique Blend of 23 Flavors

$2.79

20oz Diet Dr Pepper

$2.79

20oz Cherry Coke

Enjoy the crisp and refreshing taste with sweet, smooth cherry flavor.

$2.79

20oz Vanilla Coke

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

$2.79

20oz Coca Cola Zero Sugar

The same great taste but with zero calories.

$2.79

Powerade Zero Mixed Berry

A combination of electrolytes and carbohydrates that provide effective hydration and energy.

$2.79

Powerade Mountain Berry Blast

A combination of electrolytes and carbohydrates that provide effective hydration and energy.

$2.79

Powerade Fruit Punch

A combination of electrolytes and carbohydrates that provide effective hydration and energy.

$2.79

Canada Dry 2L

$2.99

Dr Pepper 2L

$2.99

Barqs Root Beer 2L

Classic root beer with a rich, smooth flavor in a 2-liter bottle.

$2.99

Sprite 2L

The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.

$2.99

Diet Coke 2L

A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

$2.99

Coca Cola Classic 2L

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

$2.99

Menu - 2L Beverage

Menu - Wings

Regular Wings

Chicken wings available in sizes ranging from half dozen to 4 dozen.

$0.00

Boneless Wings

Boneless chicken wings. Sizes range from half dozen to 4 dozen.

$0.00

Extra Sauce

Crispy wings with a wide range of sauce options: from mild to meat hot, including sweet thai BBQ, mango habanero, and garlic parmesan. Choose to your taste.

$0.00

*10 Plates And Napkins*

$0.00

Chicken Parm Pizza

Mozzarella, breaded chicken, marinara. Available in small, medium, large, sheet, or as a calzone.

$0.00

Four Cheese Pizza

Smothered in mozzarella, provolone, ricotta and romano.

$0.00

Chicken Wing Pizza

Chicken covered in mozzarella with your choice of wing sauce

$0.00

Meat Supreme Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon.

$0.00

Red Headed Italian

White sauce smothered in mozzarella, topped with red sauce and romano.

$0.00

Italian M.O.B. Pizza

Meatballs, bacon, and onions smothered in mozzarella.

$0.00

Pulled Pork Pizza

Texas bbq joint pulled pork slathered in your sauce, covered in mozzarella.

$0.00

Garbage Pizza

Hamburger, hot dog, home fries, macaroni, hot sauce and cheese.

$0.00

Loaded Baked Potato Pizza

Topped with creamy potato, crisp bacon, chives, and a blend of cheeses. Sizes: small to sheet, including calzone.

$0.00

Breakfast Pizza

White Sauce, eggs, cheese and bacon or sausage

$0.00

Veggie Supreme Pizza

Your choice of 5 vegetables.

$0.00

Hawaiian Style Pizza

Ham and pineapple smothered in mozzarella.

$0.00

Supreme Classic Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, onions, black olives, and green peppers.

$0.00

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Chicken and bacon smothered in mozzarella, covered with ranch

$0.00

Steak Pizza

Sauce topped with shaved steak smothered in mozzarella.

$0.00

Extra Sauce

Sauce selections for specialty pizza: mild, sweet Thai BBQ, mango habanero, medium to hot, BBQ variants, Caribbean jerk, garlic Parmesan, honey mustard, exclusive caraglio's gold BBQ, country sweet, dressings including bleu cheese, ranch, Italian, balsamic vinaigrette, spicy meat, classic marinara, ketchup, relish, mustard, or option for no sauce.

$0.00

Menu - Specialty Pizza

Menu - Keto Bowls

Keto Bowl

No crust - includes 2 toppings, cheese, and sauces.

$8.99

Philly Steak Keto Bowl

With 2 veggies

$10.99

Chicken Philly Keto Bowl

With 2 veggies

$10.99

Black Angus Burger

Black Angus Burger

$5.49

Double Burger

1/4 pound

$7.99

Chicken Breast Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast sandwich with optional American, Swiss, provolone, or mozzarella cheese.

$6.99

Red Hot

Grilled sausage with charred marks, nestled in a soft sub roll.

$5.49

White Hot

Grilled white hot sausages with a savory blend of spices, offering a traditional and robust flavor profile.

$5.49

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Tender pulled pork in a sandwich, choice of sauces including mango habanero, sweet Thai BBQ, various heats, and specialty flavors. Optional cheese: American, Swiss, provolone, mozzarella.

$5.99

Pulled Pork Sandwich W/ Cheese

$6.49

Menu - Grilled Items

Menu - Subs / Wraps

Cold Sub

All veggies can be grilled.

$11.99

Hot Sub

All veggies can be grilled.

$13.99

Cold Wrap

All veggies can be grilled.

$8.99

Hot Wrap

All veggies can be grilled.

$10.99

Extra Sauce

Select from a diverse range of sauces to enhance your sub or wrap, including options from mild to hot, sweet to savory: BBQ, jerk, mustard, Italian, and more.

$0.00

5 Chicken Fingers

Crispy chicken tenders served with a choice of sauce. Options include BBQ, honey mustard, ranch, and more.

$13.99

10 Chicken Fingers

Choice of sauce

$24.99

Buffalo Chicken Fingers

Tossed in your choice of sauce. Includes side Bleu Cheese

$14.99

4 Piece Pizza Logs

With sauce.

$8.99

8 Pc Mac & Cheese Bites

Crispy, fried macaroni bites filled with creamy cheese. Choice of sauce options: mild to hot, sweet to savory, including unique blends like Caraglio's Gold BBQ and Caribbean Jerk.

$8.99

French Fries

Crispy french fries with a variety of side sauces: mild to hot profiles, BBQ flavors, exotic options like Caraglio's Gold BBQ, and classic condiments.

$4.99

Cajun Fries

Crispy Cajun fries served with a choice of side sauces, ranging from mild to hot, sweet to savory, including sweet Thai BBQ, mango habanero, and garlic Parmesan.

$4.99

Buffalo Cheese Fries

Cheese fries topped with buffalo sauce. Optional loaded fry sauce includes sweet thai BBQ, mango habanero, garlic parmesan, and more.

$10.99

Loaded Fries

Double order of fries with cheddar or mozzarella, bacon and ranch.

$13.99

Onion Rings

Onion rings with a choice of side sauce: mild to hot options, BBQ varieties, and traditional dips.

$6.99

Fried Dough Minis

Cinnamon and sugar or powdered sugar.

$6.99

4 Apple Pie Logs

Crispy apple pie logs, choice of plain, cinnamon, powdered, or mixed sugar topping.

$8.99

6 Pc Mozzarella Stick

Mozzarella sticks, 6 pieces, with a choice of sauce including mild to hot varieties, sweet to savory flavors, and classic dips like ranch or marinara.

$7.99

2 Pc Garlic Bread

Add cheese for an additional charge.

$4.99

5 Pc Bread Sticks

With sauce.

$4.99

Caraglio’s Sampler Platter

Includes 4 sauces, 6 mozzarella sticks, 4 pizza fingers, 8 mac, and cheese wedges, and 5 chicken fingers.

$29.99

Boneless Wing Dinner

12 pcs. with fries and choice of sauce.

$15.99

Chicken Finger Dinner

5 pcs. with fries and choice of sauce.

$15.99

Fish Fry Dinner

With fries and macaroni salad.

$16.99

Deep River Kettle Chips

Crisp deep river kettle chips, an ideal appetizer.

$1.50

Cookies

Chocolate chip cookie with rich, gooey chocolate pieces.

$1.29

Mac Salad

Creamy macaroni mixed with finely chopped vegetables, tossed in a tangy dressing.

$2.99

Extra Sauce

Variety of sauces including mild, BBQ variations, exotic flavors like mango habanero, classics like honey mustard, and dressings such as ranch or balsamic vinaigrette. Option for no sauce available.

$0.00

Menu - Apps / Dinner / Desserts

Menu - Sloppy Plates

Sloppy Plate

Sloppy plate with choice of meat: hamburger, cheeseburger, red/white hot, chicken finger, pulled pork. Select sides: mac salad, home fries, fries.

$14.99

Extra Sauce

Choose from a wide selection of sauces, including sweet, spicy, and tangy options like Mango Habanero, Garlic Parmesan, and Classic BBQ or opt for no sauce.

$0.00

Mixed Greens Salads

Add meat for an additional charge.

$8.99

Extra Sauce

Choice of sauces including mild to hot options, sweet BBQ, mango habanero, jerk, garlic parmesan, honey mustard, various BBQs, Italian, and classic condiment selections.

$0.00

Menu - Salads