Welcome to Caraglio's Pizza
Caraglio's Pizza is a beloved gem nestled in Webster, NY, dedicated to crafting exceptional pizzas and grilled delights. Our story began with a passion for perfecting the art of pizza-making, offering a range of choices from traditional to gluten-free options. Customers rave about our mouthwatering crusts, vibrant sauces, and generous toppings, showcasing a commitment to quality in every bite. Whether you're indulging in our succulent pulled pork sandwiches or crispy wings, each dish embodies our dedication to flavor and service. At Caraglio's, we don't just serve food; we create memorable dining experiences that keep our community returning for more.
Caraglio's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
It looks like not everyone had the experience I did, but I really like this place. The crust is always perfect (not too thick - not too thin), the red and pink sauces are delicious, and I love the eggplant topping. Love it! Also, the wings were perfect last night.
Yes, highly recommended. 5 stars for 2 large pizzas and orders of wings. All very good... sauces included. Thick, thin whatever you want. No skimping on the toppings. Done to perfection. I was never a fan of the conveyer belt cooking process, but seems to work for Caraglio's. 3 stars for service, bc it was about 15 minutes later than expected, said they were busy, I get it...met with a 10 gift card removed the sting. The atmosphere?... Well, it's a waiting room... gotta try it. Good luck Caraglios... we'll be back, often. Just at 10/ per... can't go wrong
On behalf of the entire staff of Vision Hyundai Webster we appreciate everything you do. We have had many different pizza's and lunch programs at the dealership. However the pizza's and service we receive from your employees is the best around and second to none. Keep up the great job and many many thanks to all of you.
Loved the pizza! Was first time trying & will definitely order again!
Caraglio’s Pizza is hands down the best pizza in Rochester! Their gluten-free options are amazing, and they are always consistent with their quality and service. Recently, there was a small issue with our order due to a system error — but before we even had a chance to call, they reached out to us and let us know they were already sending the corrected order. That level of care and proactive service is rare and so appreciated. The Webster location especially is fantastic — you can tell they truly care about their customers. Highly recommend Caraglio’s if you’re looking for great pizza and service!
Update! After two years of not having their pizza due to so many issues, we have decided to try it again and it has been amazing the last 3 times! No issues and really, this is the best pizza! So glad they got new staff!!! Thank you!! *deleted old comments*
Our favorite place in Webster for pizza. The food is amazing and the staff is just as great!
Love their pizza made thin crust.... excellent. Get wings crispy with 2 sauces combo Buffalo mild & country sweet... we enjoy all verymuch
Location
-
2186 Empire Blvd, Webster, NY 14580, United States Hotline: +1 585-787-3333
Welcome to the delicious world of Caraglio's Pizza, a standout gem nestled at 2186 Empire Blvd, Webster, NY 14580. For pizza lovers seeking a unique blend of quality, flavor, and excellent service, this eatery is a must-visit. With a phone number at +1 585-787-3333 for easy reach, Caraglio's ensures that great food is just a call away.
One of the defining features of Caraglio's is their specialty pizzas. A crowd favorite is the Pulled Pork Pizza, where Texas BBQ joint pulled pork is generously slathered in your choice of sauce and covered in melted mozzarella. The menu doesn't stop there; diners can select from a variety of sauces including sweet Thai BBQ, mango habanero, and the exclusive Caraglio’s gold BBQ. This attention to sauce selection allows for a personalized experience that elevates each bite.
For health-conscious diners, Caraglio's offers keto bowls, featuring options such as Chicken Philly and Philly Steak cooked to perfection. These bowls are not only satisfying but also customizable with a selection of fresh vegetables for added flavor and nutrition.
Salads are also on the menu, with mixed greens served fresh and the option to add meat for a filling meal. Prices begin at $8.99, making it an affordable choice for those craving something light yet tasty.
- Atmosphere: While some reviews describe the ambiance as a waiting room, the focus is clearly on the food—a testament to Caraglio's commitment to quality over aesthetic flair.
- Customer Service: Numerous customers have praised the staff for their proactive engagement and friendliness. A noteworthy mention comes from Jane Balcerek, who loved her first experience and looks forward to returning.
- Quality Assurance: Morgan Kellerman highlights Caraglio's impressive gluten-free options and their dedication to consistency and customer care, which is rare in today’s dining landscape.
In conclusion, whether you are a fan of thick crust, thin crust, or somewhere in between, Caraglio's has something for everyone. With glowing reviews regarding their delicious pizzas and responsive service, this establishment has become a standout choice in the Rochester area. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to indulge in some of the best pizza around; your taste buds will thank you!